Have you ever noticed that Firestar seems to be too perfect??? The Erins made him sound like he was the best cat ever. Some more examples are.....

  • They acted like he was nearly unbeatable in battle, he won about every war
  • He lived way too long and it took him forever to die
  • He saved all the clans like a million times!! BloodClan, Dark Forest, Tigerstar (just ThunderClan), and a few more
  • He was the fourth and he has been the "main hero" many times
  • Was made a Warrior within about 200 pages
  • Was the subject of TWO really major prophocies that would save all the clans (twice!!)

So what do you think? Is Firestar the cat of perfection? Tell me your opinion!!